Admit it man, you're just afraid someone will tell you the truth, that maybe your music sucks, and I say this in no childish manner.  The reason you like iCompositions is because they coddle you over there, tell you you're doing great when in fact you're not.  You think that's going to help someone improve?  NOPE, and I say this in no immature way.  Yeah, there's ridiculous comments here, but so what?   Lighten up, laugh it off and go on to the next.  Get a backbone, grow some skin.  Usually when people are as sensitive as you it means only one thing: they have a guilty conscience of sorts, in that case, because you know deep down your music is not very strong.  If you were truly proud of it and were confident it stands on its own merits you would not be afraid to post it anywhere.  You would know what comments are valuable and what are not.  Again, you are a scared little guy afraid of finding out the truth.  I feel sorry for you, and I say this in no childish manner.  (You have a complex about being immature and childish by the way.)

Hi Jack-

You can find homebrand on the site he mentioned, icompositions.com, where you will find over 100 of his compositions.  Homebrand is his user name.  I listened to parts of a couple of his tunes.   I'm not really into loops or electronica, so I left rather hastily, but I didn't slam him.  He's but a boy, and he wouldn't want to hear what I had to say anyway. 

CA

Well, Homebrand, I can only say sorry that you don't feel like posting your songs here.  I also hope you enjoy your other site, and get some sort of commission for coming here, blasting ours, then pimping theirs.

It's true that we don't have a locked down, sanitized 'listening room' atmosphere here.  But just like in the real world, people say things under the protection of anonymity that they would never say in front of a person.  That's good and bad.

The good part is that you can (hopefully) find out exactly what the man on the street might think about your music.  That sort of information is probably fairly valuable if you ever want to get any commercial success in the industry.

The bad part is that hooligans quickly turn to hooliganism when given the opportunity to behave however they would like under the cover of darkness (in this case, anonymous posts and comments).  We don't like that any more than you do, and we have begun to increase the pressure on those we can by deleting comments that are truly worthless or offensive.

This site is fairly active, so there is no way to filter every single comment through a censorship board before it goes up.  We watch them, catch them when we can, and are now actively deleting them. We may lock everything down and force logins for rating and comments at some point, but this is how the site operates now.

You may also have noticed that you are not bombarded with ads here - in fact, there are no ads, just a link to a software partner's website.  You may also notice that it is free.  Free to join and free to post songs.  We are not in this to make money, we are in it to hear and discover good music.  We also offer that ability to anyone who wants to stroll by and check us out. 

Perhaps you can create an entire music site on your own time, offer it to people for free, and maintain it for free, then deal with complaints from people for free....but until then - maybe you could upload some of your music and leave long, detailed, relevant and upbeat feedback and give us a hand?  We have many wonderful contributors here, and are always looking for more....